Nathaniel Duckworth

Education

St. Anne's College, Oxford: M.A. Honours Modern Languages (French & Spanish), 1st Class
Paris Chamber of Commerce: Diploma in Business and Economics French
The College of Law: Diploma in Law (Commendation).

Professional

Inns of Court School of Law: Bar Vocational Course (Very Competent, graduated top 3%)
Called, Lincoln's Inn (2002).

Recent Cases

Shamsan v 44-49 Lowndes Square Management Co Ltd (2024, Court of Appeal, Nugee, Underhill and Edis LJJ). Acting for the landlord in an appeal about whether a head landlord is liable in negligence when the porters in a residential block carelessly hand over keys to a sub-tenant’s flat to a thief.
Donovan v Prescott Place Freehold Ltd [2024] EWCA Civ 298 (Asplin, Arnold and Snowdon LJJ). Acted for the successful Appellant in an appeal raising issues relating to the Landlord and Tenant Act 1987, abuse of process and injunctions.
Messenex v Lanark Square Limited [2024] EWHC 89 (Ashley Greenbank). Acted for the successful landlord at trial resisting a tenant’s claim for a declaration that consent had unreasonably been refused to redevelopment of a block of flats in London.
Amin v Amin (2024, HHJ Monty KC). Acted for the successful defendant in a seven day undue influence and misrepresentation trial.
Winchester Court Limited v Paymil (2023, HHJ Johns KC). Acted for the successful tenant in case which considers, for the first time, whether a sub-tenant of part of premises demised by a head-lease can obtain relief from forfeiture under s.146(2) of the Law of the Property Act 1925 vesting the whole of the head-lease in the sub-tenant.
AHGR Ltd v Kane [2023] EWCA Civ 428 (King, Dingemans and Snowden LJJ). Acted for the landlord in an appeal concerning whether a planning permission and user covenant in the lease which required premises to be used as a "live/work unit" should be read as requiring living and working or living and/or working.
Valley View Health Centre v NHS Property Services Limited [2022] EWHC 1393 (Edwin Johnson J). Acted for the successful landlord in five sets of proceedings concerning the liability of GPs to pay service charges to their NHS landlord.
Milestar v Gandesha (2021) (CC, HHJ Monty QC). Acted for the successful landlord in opposed lease renewal proceedings under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 in which the Court had to consider, for the first time, whether whether a landlord can succeed under Ground (b) (rent arrears) if the tenant has a right of equitable set off in an amount that is equal to or in excess of the arrears of rent.
Derhalli v Derhalli [2021] EWCA Civ 112 (Court of Appeal). Acted for the successful Respondent in a second appeal concerning the interpretation of a consent order in high value divorce proceedings.
Menzies v Louisianna Properties Ltd (2019) (High Court, HHJ Kremer) Acted for the successful appellant in an appeal relating to a claim for damages for negligence and nuisance in connection with water penetration from a suprajacent flat.
London Kendal No 3 Ltd v Daejan Investments Ltd [2019] 7 WLUK 589 (HHJ Saunders). Acted for the successful landlord at trial in commercial lease renewal proceedings under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954, in the first ground (f) case since the Supreme Court's decision in S Franses v Cavendish Hotels.
Shortland v Hill [2018] 1 P & CR 16 (HHJ Matthews) (claim for declaration as to location of a boundary and scope and enforceability of a right of way).
Pollock v Oldfield [2018] EWHC 2743 (Chancery Division, Arnold J). Acted for the successful appellant overturning a finding of fact and the first instance judge's construction of an old conveyance in boundary dispute proceedings.
Freehold Managers (Nominees) Ltd v Celestia Management Company [2017] EWHC 1281 (Chancery Division, HHJ Davis-White QC). Acted for the successful Defendant in a claim for declaratory relief as to the proper construction of an outgoings covenant in a lease forming part of a complicated leasehold scheme
Sparks v Biden [2017] EWHC 1994 (Chancery Division, HHJ Jarman QC). Acted for the Defendant in a claim for declaratory relief as to existence or otherwise of an implied term in an overage agreement
Goodlad v Tonkinson (2017) (SYK196094) – Acted for the successful respondent opposing an application to the First-tier Tribunal for a notice protecting an option agreement to be cancelled on the grounds of invalidity / unenforceability.
Westhill Endowment v Birmingham City Council (2016) (Chancery Division, HHJ Purle QC). Acted for the successful claimant in proceedings for rectification of the register of town or village greens under section 14(b) of the Commons Registration Act 1965, led by Guy Fetherstonhaugh QC.
Murdoch v Amesbury [2016] UKUT 0003 (TCC). Appeal to the Upper Tribunal (HHJ Dight), in a boundary dispute, concerning amongst other things (i) the breadth of the FTT’s discretion on an application for a determined boundary under s.60(3) of the Land Registration Act 2002 and (ii) the extent of the Ali v Lane exception to the inadmissibility of subsequent conduct.
Airport Industrial GP Ltd v Heathrow Airport Ltd [2015] EWHC 3753. Claim for specific performance of contractual obligations to build and hand over a car park in the immediate environs of Heathrow.
Safin v Badrig [2015] EWCA Civ 739. Appeal to CA about whether and if so in what circumstances the Court may vary a consent order containing a contract of compromise.
CF Business Ltd v Munday [2014] EWCA Civ 1296 (Court of Appeal decision in a mortgagee possession case raising issues of estoppel by convention and cause of action estoppel).
Ham v Ham [2013] EWCA Civ 1301 (Court of Appeal decision on the interpretation of departure provisions contained in a partnership agreement).
Director of Land Valuation v Banks (2012) Civil Appeal No 12 (Bermuda Court of Appeal: construction of the Land Valuation and Tax Act 1967)
Lancashire Insurance Co Ltd v MS Frontier Reinsurance Limited [2012] UKPC 2012 (Appeal from the Bermuda Court of Appeal: interpretation of an agreement for an assignment of a commercial lease; waiver by election)
CA Trott (Plant Hire) Ltd v Humble [2012] UKUT 391 (Lands Tribunal appeal: enfranchisement and breach of natural justice)
Director of Land Valuation v Banks (2012) Civil Appeal No 17 (Supreme Court of Bermuda: rating appeal)
Gopaul v Baksh [2012] UKPC 1 (Privy Council (Trinidad & Tobago): statutory interpretation)
Rees v Peters [2011] EWCA Civ 836 (Court of Appeal decision on restrictive covenants; alteration of the register)
Neale v Witney Electric Theatre (2011) (Court of Appeal decision on interim rent under the 1954 Act)
Forrester Ketley & Co v (1) Brent (2) Palette [2009] EWHC 3441 (Ch) (High Court fraud trial).
Royal Oak Property Co. Ltd v Iktilat and anor [2008] PLSCS 215 (High Court: Sham trusts; whether equity of redemption is a sufficient interest for the purposes of s. 2 of the Charging Orders Act 1979).
Plintal SA and another v 36-48A Edgewood Drive RTM [2008] PLSCS (Lands Tribunal: Jurisdiction of the LVT to award costs under s. 88(1) of the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Act 2002).
The Holt (Freehold) Ltd v Daejan Investments Ltd [2008] PLCS 75 (Lands Tribunal: Enfranchisement: deferment rate for non-Prime Central London property).
Blue Haven Enterprises Ltd v (1) Tully and (2) Robinson [2006] UKPC 17 (Appeal from the Jamaica Court of Appeal – proprietary estoppel/unjust enrichment).
DS (Applicant) v SS (NOW SM) (Respondent) & EM (Intervener) [2006] EWHC 2892 (Fam) (proprietary estoppel, constructive trusts; competing equities).

Publications

Co-author of Commercial and Residential Service Charges (www.bloomsburyprofessional.com/1528/Bloomsbury-Professional-Commercial-and-Residential-Service-Charges.html)
Contributor to the Woodfall Landlord and Tenant Bulletin
Contributor to the New Law Journal.

Called 2002